Unbiased Analysis of Today's Healthcare Issues

Matt Miller on Marketplace

Written By: Jason Shafrin - Dec• 21•06

Matt Miller was on NPR’s Marketplace on TuesdayMiller was advocating the creation of a government controlled health system.  While his arguments citing the benefits of nationalized health care are compelling, he does not address some of the drawbacks (e.g.: decreased technological innovation in a single payer system, increased risk of corruption, etc.).

The most interesting point Miller makes is the following: “If big-company health plans today are really just socialized health republics, for example–in which the young subsidize the old while everyone pays identical premiums–why shouldn’t this principle of risk pooling apply economy-wide?”  Nationalized health insurance would certainly increase risk sharing, but they would drastically reduce consumer choice.  Employers generally offer employees a few health care plans to choose from, and if the worker is still not satisfied, they can leave and find insurance at another firm.  In other words, if large firms are republics, then individuals may exhibit Tiebout sorting by choosing employers whose benefit package best fits their needs and this phenomenon may or may not be inefficient.
For Miller’s full article, visit the Matt Miller website.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

No Comments

  1. […] Is government provided health insurance a good thing?  Colorado Health Insurance Insider discusses whether or not Gov. Elect Bill Ritter of Colorado will be able to fill his promise of health insurance for all of the citizens of Colorado by 2010.  Michael Cannon of the Cato-at-Liberty blog criticizes Gov. Richardson’s proposal to expand Medicaid in New Mexico.  In another post, Cannon looks at the possibility that Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) could be an unlimited tax-deferral mechanism.The Healthcare Economist analyzes Matt Miller’s plan for a government controlled health system in the U.S. and his criticism of big company health plans as “socialized health republics.â€?Health […]