Unbiased Analysis of Today's Healthcare Issues

Swiss Healthcare System

Written By: Jason Shafrin - Nov• 27•07

Maggie Mahar has a interesting post discussing the Swiss health care system (“Herzlinger’s Meme on Switzerland and Consumer Driven Medicine“). The Swiss government mandates that all individuals purchase health insurance. While the insurance is subsidized by the government–and more heavily subsidized for poor Swiss individuals–most Swiss pay a large percentage of their insurance premiums. The government pays 25% of the premium while the individual pays the rest. Is having a “skin in the game” what is creating a more efficient health care system, where Switzerland has lower health care spending and better medical outcomes? Ms. Mahar doesn’t believe it (and neither do I):

But the truth is that Swiss patients have relatively little say over either the cost or the quality of the care they receive. Prices are regulated by the government, which also tries to make sure that consumers are getting value for their health care dollars by selecting which drugs, devices and tests insurance will cover. In fact, it is the very visible hand of a smart, largely efficient government that accounts for Switzerland’s relative success.

The key to consumer driven health plans (as recommended by Regina Herzlinger in the WSJ and JAMA 2004) is that 1) consumers–not employers–are the ones choosing their own health plans and 2) that consumers have adequate information regarding the quality of the plan.  The paradox of the Swiss system is that while the Swiss do decide their own plan and have quality information regarding their plan benefits, this quality information comes due to the fact that the government strictly regulates a minimum benefit.  This minimum benefit package on the one hand makes it easier for consumers to know what their health plan will cover, but on the other reduces the consumer’s health plan options and makes the health insurance system less “consumer-driven.”

Thanks to Joe Paduda for the link.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

6 Comments

  1. Brenda says:

    Sadly, a lot of politicians are talking of doing this in America. As it is, Medicare Premiums have increased and will continue to do so, making it very hard for those on fixed income and the elderly to pay their insurance. But the big companies don’t think of this as they sit back and collect their money!!! AARP has set up http://www.thisissoridiculous.com so we can sign a petition to make our voice heard. They also offer a lot of updated info and videos on the subject, as well as an easy link to e-mail your congressman to let him know how you feel! Im working with AARP to promote better Medicare because this is STILL America and we still have our rights…

  2. […] Maggie Mahar has a interesting post discussing the Swiss health care system (”Herzlinger s Meme on Switzerland and Consumer Driven Medicine“). The Swiss government mandates that all individuals purchase health insurance. While the insurance is subsidized by the government–and more heavily subsidized for poor Swiss individuals–most Swiss pay a large percentage of their […] Read more […]

  3. […] November, I wrote a post about the Swiss healthcare system. Today, I am giving you a bullet-point summary, offering more detail concerning healthcare in […]

  4. […] this blog, I have written about the Swiss (part one, part two) and Dutch healthcare system extensively. Both systems have a “regulated […]

  5. […] have already written about Switzerland in previous posts (see Swiss Healthcare Sytem: Part I, and Part II). Still of all the countries with universal health care, Switzerland’s is the […]

  6. […] have already written about Switzerland in previous posts (see Swiss Healthcare Sytem: Part I, and Part II). Still of all the countries with universal health care, Switzerland’s is the […]