Unbiased Analysis of Today's Healthcare Issues

Health Care Around the World: France

Written By: Jason Shafrin - Apr• 14•08

France is often seen by liberals as the ideal system. It has universal health care, with few waiting lists. France has the highest level of satisfaction with their health care among all European countries. How can this be? What is their secret?

France provides a basic, universal health insurances through large occupation-based funds. The General National Health Inusrance Scheme covers 83% of French workers, while other occupational specific (e.g.: for agricultural workers, for the self employed, for miners, etc.) cover the remainder. About 99% of individuals are covered by this universal health insurance system.

However, France utilizes more market-based ideas than most people realized. Copayment rates for most services are 10%-40%. About 92% of French residents have complementary private health insurance.

In essence, the French system avoids widespread rationing because, unlike true single-payer systems, it employs market forces. Even the OECD says that the “proportion of the population with private health insurance” and the degree of cost sharing are key determinants of how severe waiting lists will be.

Insured. About 99% of French residents are covered by the national health insurance scheme.

Cost. France is the third most expensive health care system (~11% of GDP). While the system has generally been well funded, in 2005 the health care system ran a €11.6 billion deficit and in 2006 the health care system had a €10.3 billion deficit. No centrally planned health insurance system will be immune from occasional (or even frequent) deficits.

Funding. Most of the funding is from a 13.55% payroll tax (employers pay 12.8%, individuals pay 0.75%). There is a 5.25% general social contribution tax on income as well. Thus, there is an approximately a 18.8% on employees for health insurance. There are also dedicated taxes which are assessed on tobacco, alcohol, and pharmaceutical company revenues.

Private Insurance. “More than 92% of French residents have complementary private insurance.” This insurance pays for additional fees in order to access higher quality providers. Private health insurances makes up 12.7% of French health care spending. These complementary private insurance funds are very loosely regulated (less than in the U.S.) and the only stringent requirement is guaranteed renewability. Private insurance benefits are not equally distributed so there is, in essence, a two-tier system.

Physician Compensation. French doctors are paid by the national health insurance system based on a centrally planned fee schedule, but doctors can charge whatever price they want. The fees are based on an up front treatment lump sum, which is similar to DRGs in the U.S. The patient–or their private insurance–must make up the difference between the fee charged by the doctor and the amount paid for by the universal health care system. The average French doctor earns only €40,000, although medical school is free for them and the French legal system is fairly tort-averse.

Physician Choice. The French have a fair amount of choice in which doctors they choose. However, recently the French have moved towards a more “managed care” practice style where patients have a “preferred doctors” who acts as a gatekeeper for specialists.

Copayment/Deductibles. 10% to 40% copayments.

Technology. The government does not reimburse new technologies very generously and because of global budgets and fee restrictions, there is little incentive to make capital investments in medical technology.

Waiting Times. France has generally avoided waiting lists, likely due to the fairly high coinsurance charges. Recent trends towards Increased restrictions, reduced reimbursement rates, and rationing has increased wait times however.

Tanner’s summary. “To sum up: the French health care system clearly works better than most national health care systems. Despite some problems, France has generally avoided the rationing inherent in other systems. However, the program is threatened by increasing costs and may be forced to resort to rationing in the future.”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

18 Comments

  1. barry says:

    so interesting!
    thanks
    ~Barry

  2. [...] to feed « Sick Around the World: PBS  •  Health Care Around the World: France [...]

  3. [...] French cuisine and the rising cost of rice (Times Online) Paradis found – Music (The Phoenix) Health Care Around the World: France (Healthcare [...]

  4. [...] France | Italy | Spain | Japan | Norway | Portugal | Greece | Great Britain | Switzerland | Germany | Canada [...]

  5. [...] mentioned in previous posts, most health insurance in the France public health care system involves significant copayments. [...]

  6. [...] nationwide is guaranteed renewal.  Although some consider this proof of the superiority of market-based solutions if left alone from government interference, the why is pretty obvious – you don’t need them.  [...]

  7. [...] nationwide is guaranteed renewal.  Although some consider this proof of the superiority of market-based solutions if left alone from government interference, the why is pretty obvious – you don’t need them.  [...]

  8. [...] have some form of private insurance, even the ones deemed to be ’socialist.’  France lets individuals ‘top-up’ the government health insurance scheme with private [...]

  9. [...] Your pay is taxed 18.8% total, 92% buy additional private insurance AND citizens still pay a 10% to 40% co-payment. __________________ (*Disclaimer: The preceding is a Professor Peabody opinion, not to be [...]

  10. [...] that, it's what my co-pay was when I had insurance. Even Government run health care has copays, in France it's 10% to 40% of the bill. The average cost of a hip replacement is $35,0000 some sources say $25,000 and others [...]

  11. [...] that, it's what my co-pay was when I had insurance. Even Government run health care has copays, in France it's 10% to 40% of the bill. The average cost of a hip replacement is $35,0000 some sources say $25,000 and others [...]

  12. [...] is my previous review of the French healthcare system.  Below is the some additional information on medical care in France based on the book by William [...]

  13. [...] I’m sure there’s a logic to this which goes beyond “The French Suck!”  But I can’t imagine that this guy has actually done any research into the French Healthcare system. [...]

  14. [...] has national healthcare yet patient medical records are not linked due to the interoperability between systems. There are [...]

  15. [...] restrictions, reduced reimbursement rates, and rationing has increased wait times however. http://healthcare-economist.com/2008…-world-france/ 18% X $65,000 (income) = $11,700 a year not including the private insurance premium. According [...]