Unbiased Analysis of Today's Healthcare Issues

In Support of a Fake Doctor

Written By: Jason Shafrin - Dec• 14•10

Recently, MSNBC reported that respected cardiologist and United Airlines captain Dr. William Hamman is in fact not a doctor at all.  “The AP found he had no medical residency, fellowship, doctoral degree or the 15 years of clinical experience he claimed. He attended medical school for a few years but withdrew and didn’t graduate.”  As a result, “Journals that printed articles listing Hamman with M.D. and Ph.D. degrees are being contacted in case they want to correct the work. Beaumont removed him from a U.S. Department of Defense medical simulation contract that a physician at the hospital had obtained.”

Dr. Hamman lied.  He lied about his credentials and should be punished for that.

What news articles are not covering, however, is the quality of work Dr. Hamman did.  If Dr. Hamman conducted heart surgery without the proper training, then that is a serious issue.  According to the news report, however, “There is no indication Hamman ever treated a patient.”

Instead, Dr. Hamman’s training sessions used an operations research framework from his background as a pilot in order to help Doctor’s improve quality.  His training was typically titled, “This is Your Captain Speaking: What can we learn about patient safety from the airlines?”  They were so successful, that “Even after learning of Hamman’s deception, the American Medical Association was going to let him lead a seminar that had been in the works, altering his biography and switching his title from ‘Dr.’ to ‘Captain’ on course materials. It was canceled after top officials found out.”

It is possible that the only way for Dr. Hamman to gain the respect of his peers or even gain entry into the world of medicine is with an MD.  Nevertheless, this does not mean that Dr. Hamman could not have conducting high quality training seminars to maximize physician teamwork.

One of my friend’s who is a physician actually worked with Hamman.  The physician said that Hamman seemed legitimate.  He never talked about clinical issues, only simulation and teamwork issues.

On the personal level, this story is about a man who lied and lacked integrity.  On a system level, this story may actually tell more about physicians’ efforts to prohibit non-physicians from providing any services even remotely related to medical care–such as Mr. Hamman’s teamwork training.  Physician efforts to protect their turf is legendary…this may be the real story.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

5 Comments

  1. Hi Jason, good post. I agree the story is less about this individual than about the problem of self-regulating, licensed professions. Clearly, a lot of intelligent and thoughtful people appreciated and valued his work, and they have lost out with his removal. If the story were about a very effective businessman who had a profitable operation and satisfied customers and employees, but who turned out to have faked an MBA, I doubt people would cry out for him to be forcibly removed as the owner. I hope (naively) that people remember this story the next time the AMA (BMA, CMA, etc.) cry out that they need a monopoly in order to protect the public.

  2. bubber says:

    Hamman is a fraud.

    Just illustrates how, even in the “science” of medicine, bright ones can be duped.

    Are there any REAL doctors who are also airline pilots?

  3. Hank says:

    If he lied about this, do you really think he hasn’t lied before, about more stuff, to his family and friends? The credibility question is less about this incident than the compulsiveness to lie repeatedly, over and over, to everyone. Check deeper, likely your ‘admiration’ will fade. The gain is ill-gotten, return it.

  4. M says:

    I worked with Mr. aka “Dr” Hamman very closely for over a year. I personally watched him lie over and over again. When he was caught, he continued to lie. He is intelligent fraud, nothing more.

  5. [...] Airline pilot with fake doctor’s credentials teaches doctors how to improve quality. Jason Shafrin defends him. [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>