Capitalism

You are currently browsing articles tagged Capitalism.

John Kay offers a European perspective on the debate of between the superiority of a market economy against a centrally planned economy.  Is there empirical evidence that a market economy is superior?  John Kay says yes:

The fall of the Berlin Wall in November 1989 …marked the end of the most extensive controlled experiment in the history of social sciences – the division of Germany into two economic zones, one centralised and planned, the other a market economy. After forty years, the gap in living standards between the two was so extreme that the experiment was terminated.

Why is capitalism so successful over the long run?  Kay gives 3 reasons:

  • Prices act as signals; the operation of the price mechanism is a better guide to resource allocation than central planning
  • Markets function as a process of discovery, the chaotic process of experimentation through which a market economy adapts to change…Centralised systems experiment too little. They find reasons why new proposals will fail – and mostly they are right in their suspicions, because most experiments do fail. But market economies thrive on a continued supply of unreasonable optimism.
  • Markets yield benefits from the diffusion of political and economic power… A one sentence description of why some countries are poor and others rich is that the politics and economics of poor countries are dominated by rent-seeking and the politics and economics of rich countries are not.

But isn’t a market economy one motivated solely by greed?  Can a country motivated solely by greed be successful?  According to Kay, “This is the economic environment of Nigeria and Haiti, and it does not work.”  Instead, the greed must be tempered through the mechanisms of trust relationships and reputation.  To get a broader perspective, Kay concludes with the following:

Markets are not a well-oiled machine: they more closely resemble a constantly changing, adaptive biological system. Pluralism is their motive force, their essence is chaotic, their development inherently uncertain. If we could predict the evolution of markets, we would not need markets in the first place.

Source: Kay, John (2009) “The Rationale of the Market Economy: A European Perspective,” Capitalism and Society: Vol. 4: Iss. 3, Article 1.

Tags: , , ,

Capitalism has taken a beating the past few years.  From the mortgage crisis to Bernie Madoff’s ponzi scheme, from a falling stock market to rising unemployment, capitalism does not seems like the best economic system at present.  In fact, Michael Moore even made a movie satirically titled Capitalism: A Love Story.

Yet now is not the time to abandon capitalism.  It offers the best hope to jump start the economy and–more importantly–generate long term progress.  The Economist offers 3 reasons why capitalism must be praised:

  1. Creates cooperation between sometimes antagonistic parties.  ”…companies in fact depend on persuading large numbers of people—workers and bosses, shareholders and suppliers—to work together to a common end. This involves getting lots of strangers to trust each other.”
  2. Increases innovation.  ”Business people do not just invent clever products that solve nagging problems, …[t]hey also create organisations that manufacture these products and then distribute them about the world.”
  3. Maintains political pluralism.  ”Only 202 of the 500 biggest companies in America in 1980 were still in existence 20 years later.”

Most importantly, however, is that capitalism is provides a more open society.  Anyone can earn a living, even if you don’t come from money or are a recent immigrant.  Although of course, privileged individuals do better in any society, capitalism doesn’t preclude individuals from occupations if they are from certain backgrounds or castes.  Further, capitalistic governments tend to meddle less in individuals affairs and uphold individual freedoms.  Least we forget, the Nazi’s were from the National Socialist party. [Although to be fair, socialist governments can uphold individual freedoms and capitalist countries can also oppress minorities as well.]

A paper by the Indepenent Instiute claims that businessmen are more honest than preachers, politicians, and professors.  Although businessmen can make untrue claims just like these other professions, because customers can “test drive” the products sold, the truth regarding the  product will come out eventually. This gives the businessmen an incentive to be honest up front in order to maintain long term relationships with customers and suppliers.

In the words of Winston Churchill, ”The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings. The inherent virtue of Socialism is the equal sharing of miseries.”

Tags: ,

According to Rasmussen Reports:

  • 53% of American adults believe capitalism is better than socialism,
  • 20% believe socialism is better, and
  • 27% are undecided.

Tags: ,

The S&P 500 is down 41% compared to last year.  The unemployment rate in the U.S. is now at 6.7%.  Large financial institutions are failing and droves of homeowners are defaulting on their mortgages.  Is it time to give up on capitalism?

Before we hand over the keys to the economy to President-elect Barack Obama, we should first heed this sage advice from Milton Friedman (video).

Tags: , ,